Новости

Why did Andrey decided to become a traitor?

Question on the work of Nikolai Vasilyevich Gogol "Taras Bulba".

Judging by the way Nikolai Vasilyevich describes this in his work, the cause of everything became love. Just asked Orthodox Andria to fall in love without memory to the Polish beauty, Catholic. And this love was blocked by him, and deprived him of mind, and hit from the true path, the father of the mother was defined. He loved every cell of his body and wanted only her. She was his passion and tenderness. And he was ready for a kiss and polka caress to go all. And betrayal to commit, weapons against their own same, shoot in the Cossacks, with whom he was written in the family. He was fascinated by the beauty of the girl. And he still became that she was in the enemy, that her countrymen kill his countrymen.

His love for her overpowed all the other feelings, exceeded the debt.

And he betrayed his to be with her.

However, his harsh father, Taras Bulba reasoned quite differently. For him, love for his homeland and a sense of debt were the highest. Love for a woman he, of course, recognized, but not at the cost of betrayal.

**

That is why he himself, with his own hands he shot the youngest son, as if interrupting betrayal, not giving the right to the traitor to live on Earth. This execution, through the flour, fatherly love and suffering, was also the duty of Taras Bulba, "thoring" traitor.

The system chose this answer as the best.

Egypt [435K]

More than a year ago

Andri in no case decided to become a traitor! He made his choice between love and homeland, but not in order to bet, but to remain himself between the two began: love for a woman, love for his homeland. But this is by no means for the reason that by their nature he is a traitor! He is a very sensitive young man who in a gust throws to the legs of the beloved all that can make for her. He did not make the meaning of the existence of "betrayal". He did the meaning - love.

If we argue with the words of Junken Junken, then Andria cannot be blamed in treason. As the Jew put it, he did not betray anyone, moving to someone else's side, against his own, as he made an act not forced. He did it voluntarily, at the direction of the heart. And the person cannot be blamed that he made in his will, and not forced, as he chose a happy life, and not feared for himself. He was not captive, he was called and he came. These are very difficult feelings, judging this is not easy. But remember again that the Hero N. V. Gogol has a real prototype Okhrim Makura and his sons, one of whom the love moved to the other side.

The author describes the complex feelings of the militant impulse of the soul of a loved one, a dusty young man, his immaturity of character (Ostap, the older son of the Bulba, more like her father, he was more ordered and did not choose between love and homeland, besides Ostap older than his brother). Gogol does not blame and does not justify the main character, he advises him to take what is. That for him is not a coward who betrayed his war, but a man who lost his head from love. But he came to his senses when he saw, far ahead of Lyakhov on the horse of his father, like a student of his teacher, at once attening, immediately understanding the situation. He did not resist when his father learned to violence ... And the elder brother expressed regret for the act of his father.

Cat Murochka [310K]

More than a year ago

Andriy fell in love with Panley, he could not think about anything else, as the beautiful eyes of his beautiful Pannochka.

Andria had a choice to stay faithful to his homeland or save Punkochka, he chose love. For the sake of love, Andry becomes a traitor, probably when he walked to save Pannachka, he did not even think about betrayal.

Of course, such a act from Andria, his father Cossack Taras Bulba did not expect him, he was confident in his sons and therefore the news that Andrii betrayed his homeland for him was a big blow.

The ending of this work is tragic, Taras Bulba himself crashes with his son Andrieiy, Ostap dies in the terrible torment. The Bulba himself also dies.

Imperatable rain [105K]

More than a year ago

He became a traitor to Andry through a large love for the Polish Pannachka, the daughter of the governor. Pannochka said Andrie, that it is impossible to love it, as they are the enemies that his covenant is his father, his depreciation and his comrades. Andriy answered this to her beloved that he had no one.

He had no such strong love for his homeland, to His Ukraine. He spoke Pannachka that the step rate is what the soul is looking for, and his soul is she. And that he will sell everything and charge for such a depression.

In front of Andriy became a difficult choice, between love for a girl and love for the debris, he chose a love for the girl, so he became a traitor in his eyes.

Lady V. [630K]

2 years ago

And Andry did not solve the traitor at all. He just refused one love for another. He did not think about the consequences, because his head was busy only with his heart Pannochka.

He did not plunge specially betrayal and literally until the last moment, to a meeting with the Tatarka-maid, Andry, not doubting Bil Lyakhov's mortal fight, showing the wonder of the wonders of Harrost and Taras fairly proud of such a warlike son.

But love is such a whole feeling that it is capable of overshadowing everything else. Andriy lost his head from love and no one was needed. He just forgot that he had a comrades, forgot about his brother and father, forgot about his homeland. He resolutely announced that for now there is no depreciation, and his father ordered that he has no father.

And already thus discovered all the ways to retreat, he found what was made by the traitor. For Andria, this happened as if by itself, he sailed downstream, without reflecting on what it would lead. Moreover, love was apparently mutual.

But for the Cossacks and the Father, of course, he immediately turned out to be a traitor.

Maksimenko. [273K]

More than a year ago

After reading the work, we clearly understand that Andria and in thoughts did not have to betray their homeland.

He so sought to get into the Schish and protect his native land. And in no case was not going to become a traitor.

But by nature he was in love.

I loved the Polish Pannet.

And when it came to choose between relatives and love. Chose the second.

It is a pity he became when he learned that his beltenious Pannach was starving behind the walls of the precipitated town. And he could not resist his feeling of pity and love.

Unscrew it this feeling. Split his head.

For love and gentle gentle, he betrayed his native father and brother and the entire Cossack's army. But there was no evil intent on his side. Not for Zlatto and the awards he went to betrayal. But only love for the sake of. He fascinated his paniak to such an extent that for her sake he stood in the ranks of our enemies. And with them went to fight against his.

For what and folded his head.

I did not forgive the father of treason. Samulatically killed a traitor. After all, for the Taras of Bulba, love for the Motherland was above all.

Brusn1974.

[9]

4 years ago

The story "Taras Bulba" closer to romanticism than to realism. Ungrateful occupation to discuss it from the point of view of our realities. But what I will say against Andria and those like him. Who or rather, what did he fall in love? In the pretty face? What does he know about his poison except that she is beautiful? The momentary passion, lust and everything and everything is forgotten. Brother, with which for many years lived side by side (remember how he wakes up on the left, when he leaves the camp), the mother who runs behind him in the steppe to say goodbye, father, his homeland ... who will give a guarantee that you remain Alive, in a year he would not have gone to another pool, Ukrainian, Tatar, simply because he would have wanted. Egoism is bad in everything, and in love is especially bad. The author clearly sorry to Andria, the only time he calls Taras a terrible word in the scene of the murder of his son, and I feel sorry for young cotton who deceased because of his egoism. But justify him, say, they say, "the choice of such a choice" is dismissal.

Alena Sunny

[93.4K]

5 years ago

Taras Bulba is the great work of Nicholas Gogol. Here the theme of patriotism, love for the Motherland, a man's torment in front of the choice between duty and love, family problems (relationships of Taras Bulba with sons) are touched upon here. Why is Andry considered a traitor? Because he moves to the side of his love - the pool, and it is impossible to condemn it for it. He is in love and wants to protect his beloved from enemies, wants to save her from hunger and from the cold. Between the debt in front of the birthplace and family and love he chooses the second. His choice surprises and disappointing the Father - the True Cossack, for whom the homeland was always in the first place. But Andry is softer by nature than father. He is a romantic, but not a warrior. And he also does a good choice, but for it pays his life.  Edgar Metzengerstein.

[114K]

Still would! Warrior (especially the son of the Colonel) would decorate this pole and did not fall a dilemma, love or homeland. For myself, I would stole, not for soldier rapes. If she is adamant - he would not mind her, just admired. Would disappear with her under the pretext that she should go in exchange for prisoners and therefore should not be close to the enemy fortress (and in fact - to make her eyes with her beauty do not cure). Then, let's say, the commandant of the Polish fortress displays the prisoners, they are blocked, and the Pole remains with the one in which it has already managed to fall in love. Or, if she is already tired of his petty household harm, it is honestly returned in exchange for prisoners.

4 years ago

Rose Mira [34.3K]

Still would! Warrior (especially the son of the Colonel) would decorate this pole and did not fall a dilemma, love or homeland. For myself, I would stole, not for soldier rapes. If she is adamant - he would not mind her, just admired. Would disappear with her under the pretext that she should go in exchange for prisoners and therefore should not be close to the enemy fortress (and in fact - to make her eyes with her beauty do not cure). Then, let's say, the commandant of the Polish fortress displays the prisoners, they are blocked, and the Pole remains with the one in which it has already managed to fall in love. Or, if she is already tired of his petty household harm, it is honestly returned in exchange for prisoners.

3 years ago

Because of love for a woman, beautiful Pannachka, Andry became a traitor. It was love forced him to forget about the father, brother, other Cossacks. The paylae was harsh - the young man was killed by his own father, who did not give up betrayal.

52371048.

[151k]
[151k]

The gloom of a distant restless era reports the unfortunate love and death of Andria, the youngest son of Taras. Love fell on him. This Cossack fell in love with a beautiful panley. With her beauty, Pannochka blinded him, Andriy Dresil only about her. When he learned that his beloved was in the fortress, deposited by the Cossacks, he breaks into the city, betraying his homeland, saving his tragic love, his beloved and family of Pannochki. On his armchair son, a traitor sent a gun Taras Bulba.

Do you know the answer?

The story of Nikolai Vasilyevich Gogol to everyone knows and most readers have no doubt that Andriy is a traitor. In the book - I agree, albeit with mitigating circumstances, but the Film of 2009 caused me another impression.
The story of Nikolai Vasilyevich Gogol to everyone knows and most readers have no doubt that Andriy is a traitor. In the book - I agree, albeit with mitigating circumstances, but the Film of 2009 caused me another impression.

Subscribe to the channel and pack like! You will help the development of the canal! Thank you in advance!

In the story of Andry, although he studied well, it was not understood. They guide emotions, not all of them are bad, they are simply different not appreciated in its environment. The younger son of Taras among the Cossacks - "White Voron". All Bursaki prefer the company and violent fun, Andriy wanders around the city, admiring the architecture.

Cossacks for women are honored, Andriy hugging her mother and, judging by the stories of the Polyakka, with her in trusting relationships. In the love of women, he will feel the most important happiness of life. What do not say - it bribes it. I can in the church, the organ music, Andry forgets, why came.

Frame from the film "Taras Bulba".

The young man, undoubtedly, with the abilities and a thin soul, but at the same time without any solid principles. Vanity and arrogance is also there, but there is a nobility: Gogol notes that both Sons of Taras avoided the robbery and murder of unarmed, showing only a valor in battle.

Nevertheless, Andriy, definitely, the wrong thing and the most invalid act for me, not even a fight with his own, and the warning of the boasting was sent with the nonsense, that he dies from everyone and will fight without mercy, although he overestimated himself: the appearance of his father immediately He sled.

The story of Nikolai Vasilyevich Gogol to everyone knows and most readers have no doubt that Andriy is a traitor. In the book - I agree, albeit with mitigating circumstances, but the Film of 2009 caused me another impression.
The story of Nikolai Vasilyevich Gogol to everyone knows and most readers have no doubt that Andriy is a traitor. In the book - I agree, albeit with mitigating circumstances, but the Film of 2009 caused me another impression.

So, Andria, confused in his own feelings, it is even sorry for Gogol, but he is to blame.

In the film, the younger son of Taras Bulba, not some beauty seen in the Greek-Roman classics. He learned to put questions and sought in his life the right answers to them, without satisfaction with the general opinion. For disclosure of his views, a conversation with a brother after a brutal hoody execution of the Cossack is very important.

Ostap regrets executed, because his, the Cossack, and Andry asks, is it really not sorry for any person, at least Lyach, for which the brother replies that let them feel sorry. Andriy objects about the court, about the legality, but for Ostap it is all someone else's, unimportant, and the whole Latin was something imposed, the main love for his native land, an emotional connection with her.

He clearly divides people on his and strangers. Why set unnecessary issues if there is a community from native land, with comrades?

The story of Nikolai Vasilyevich Gogol to everyone knows and most readers have no doubt that Andriy is a traitor. In the book - I agree, albeit with mitigating circumstances, but the Film of 2009 caused me another impression.
The story of Nikolai Vasilyevich Gogol to everyone knows and most readers have no doubt that Andriy is a traitor. In the book - I agree, albeit with mitigating circumstances, but the Film of 2009 caused me another impression.

Here, the eldest brother is guided by emotions, and the younger prevents all the awakened mind to take everything on faith, prompting that everything is more difficult in life that anyone has the right to be judged in actions, and not by nationality, faith and kinship, that any human life is valuable.

It is significant that Andriy fell in love with the Polyakka, he entails a mysterious girl who was not related to the usual life and in European culture a wide and interesting world, more responsible for his requests. I think that such Andry is sooner or later anyway would have left the juice, and I would have left without the Pole.

His curious and seeking truth nature is closely as part of its environment. Such Andry understands that his homeland is not only Ukraine, but also the compolutely compulculated that the state created on a voluntary basis, and not by occupation, one, even if people live in different nationality and faith.

He understands that conflicts should be solved by a legitimate way and is completely illegal that part of the state army than the Cossack army comes along its land, crushing the right and guilty. Fate puts it before choosing: to be on the side of the Father and Brother or to protect the beloved girl and the future child and Andriy chooses the side of the weakest. He knows that fighting against his own conscience, feels what is doomed, just look at him during the battle. And to throw your favorite woman to be confused by the same Cossacks, he knows about whose cruelty to foreigners, according to conscience?

Well, when life gives a choice between good and evil, but often it makes you choose between one evil and others. In this light, Andry is not a traitor, but a tragic hero who is trying to do noble in a predetermined situation.


Добавить комментарий